Understanding the Key Differences Between Commission-Based, Fee-Based and Fee-Only Financial Advisors and Their Impact on Your Future

Seeking a financial planner that aligns with your goals can be very similar to searching for the right medical professional to best meet your healthcare needs. Some doctors charge directly for their services, others earn money by recommending certain treatments, and some do a mix of both. Similarly, in the financial world, advisors come in different forms: commission-based, fee-based and fee-only. Understanding the key differences between the three is crucial for your financial future. 

Commission-Based Financial Advisors

The Pharmaceutical Reps

Commission-based financial advisors can be compared to pharmaceutical representatives who earn their income by promoting specific medications. They do not charge clients directly for their advice; instead, they earn commissions from the financial products they sell, such as mutual funds, insurance policies, or annuities. This model allows clients to receive financial advice without upfront out-of-pocket costs. Commission-based advisors’ income is directly tied to the amount of the products they sell.

How They Work

Commission-based advisors can face a high potential for conflicts of interest, similar to how pharmaceutical representatives might promote certain medications due to financial incentives. These advisors may prioritize selling products that generate higher commissions for themselves, even if those products are not the best fit for the client. 

Additionally, the lack of transparency regarding the commissions earned can erode trust, as clients might not always be aware of how much their advisor is making from their investments, leading to concerns about the advisor's impartiality.


Fee-Based Financial Advisors

The General Practitioners

Fee-based financial advisors are comparable to general practitioners (GPs) in the healthcare system. GPs offer a broad range of services and charge a fee for their consultations. Similarly, fee-based advisors provide financial services and charge clients a combination of fees and commissions. This hybrid model creates a variety of ways to charge for financial services to cater to a variety of financial needs, from investment management to retirement planning.

How They Work

Fee-based advisors earn their commissions on the products they sell, such as mutual funds, insurance policies, or annuities. Additionally, they may charge a flat fee, which can be billed hourly, monthly, or annually. This dual compensation structure can be beneficial because it offers flexibility in how clients pay for services. Fee-based advisors can provide a range of services, making them a one-stop-shop for many financial needs. Their model allows for flexibility, as the combination of fees and commissions can be tailored to suit the client's specific financial situation and preferences. One thing to be aware of is that fee-based advisors may face potential conflicts of interest similar to a general practitioner who might recommend specific treatments due to financial incentives. Advisors might be inclined to suggest products that generate a commission for them, even if those products are not the best fit for the client. The dual fee structure of fee-based advising can introduce complexity, leaving clients potentially confused about what they are paying for and how it affects their overall financial planning.


Fee-Only Financial Advisors

The Specialists

Fee-only financial advisors are like medical specialists who charge only for their expert services. Just as a cardiologist charges a fee for a consultation and treatment plan without earning extra from prescribing medications, fee-only advisors charge their clients solely for the advice and planning services they provide. They do not earn commissions from selling financial products. Working with a fee-only financial advisor puts the advisor on the side of their client, aligning their goals. 

How They Work

Fee-only advisors charge clients directly for their services. This can be in the form of an hourly rate, a flat annual fee, or a percentage of assets under management (AUM). Their compensation is transparent and solely tied to the advice and services they provide. Because fee-only advisors are fiduciaries, they are legally bound to act in their clients' best interests, offering clients an extra sense of security. While a fee-based advisor might seem more expensive upfront because their fees are not subsidized by commissions, this approach ensures that the advisor’s interests match those of their clients, resulting in greater transparency and, for many, increased trustworthiness.  Since their income isn’t tied to product sales but rather the advice they provide and planning work they perform, fee-only planners are generally more focused on helping you achieve long-term financial goals rather than meeting their short-term sales objectives. Overall, fee-only financial planners offer a structure that aims to minimize conflicts of interest and provide a more transparent, objective approach to managing your financial affairs.



Making the Right Choice: Factors to Consider

Choosing the right type of financial advisor depends on your specific needs, preferences, and circumstances, which might include: 

1. Complexity of Your Financial Situation: If your financial needs are complex and you require a broad range of services, a fee-only advisor (the specialist) might be the best fit. They can offer long-term, comprehensive solutions that are adaptable to various financial situations.

2. Desire for Objectivity: If you prioritize objective advice free from conflicts of interest, a fee-only advisor (the specialist) is likely the best choice. Their compensation model ensures that their advice is aligned with your best interests.

3. Budget Considerations: If you are cost-sensitive or prefer not to pay upfront fees, a commission-based advisor (the pharmaceutical rep) might be appealing. They provide access to financial advice without direct costs, although it's essential to be aware of potential biases in their product recommendations.

4. Transparency and Trust: Understanding how your advisor is compensated and how that might influence their advice is crucial. Transparency in fees and commissions helps build trust and ensures you are getting advice that genuinely benefits your financial health.

Navigating Your Financial Health 

By understanding the differences between these three models and considering your specific needs, you can make an informed decision that supports your long-term financial goals. With Out of the Box Financial Planning, you can trust that you’re working with a fee-only fiduciary, a Certified Financial Planner™️ practitioner who is focused on your financial well-being. We provide tailored advice on retirement planning, asset management, tax strategies, and beyond, helping you navigate potential obstacles with confidence. Remember, the right advisor can be a powerful ally in navigating the complexities of financial planning, much like the right doctor can guide you through the intricacies of health care.






Ivan Havrylyan
Financial Mistakes to Avoid When Paying for College

Paying for college can feel a lot like preparing for a long road trip. You want to make sure you have a full tank of gas, a clear map, and a plan for the unexpected detours that might come your way. As a financial advisor, I've seen many parents hit bumps in the road when it comes to funding their children's education. Here are some common financial mistakes to avoid to ensure your journey is as smooth as possible.


 

Mistake 1: Not Starting Early Enough

Think of saving for college like planting a tree. The best time to plant it was 20 years ago; the second-best time is now. Many parents delay saving for college until their child is in high school, but by then, they’ve missed out on years of potential growth. Starting early, even with small amounts, can make a big difference thanks to the power of compound interest. Consider opening a 529 savings plan when your child is young, and contribute regularly. This will give your savings time to grow, like a tree growing taller and stronger over the years.

Mistake 2: Ignoring scholarships and grants

Imagine leaving a coupon on the kitchen counter before heading to the store, only to realize at the checkout that you could have saved a bundle. Scholarships and grants are like those forgotten coupons. Many families don’t put in the effort to research and apply for these opportunities, missing out on free money that can significantly reduce college costs. Encourage your child to apply for as many scholarships and grants as possible. Every little bit helps, and it can add up to substantial savings.

Mistake 3: Underestimating the total cost of college

Planning for college is not just about tuition; it’s also about books, housing, meals, and other living expenses. It’s like budgeting for a vacation but forgetting to account for meals, souvenirs, and excursions. Make sure you consider all aspects of college costs to avoid being blindsided by unexpected expenses. Create a comprehensive budget that includes tuition, fees, room and board, textbooks, transportation, and personal expenses.


mistake 4: relying too heavily on student loans

Taking out student loans can be tempting, much like using a credit card to pay for a big purchase. It’s easy to swipe the card and worry about paying it off later. However, loans need to be repaid with interest, and relying too heavily on them can lead to a mountain of debt after graduation. Encourage your child to consider work-study programs, part-time jobs, and other means of earning money to reduce the need for loans. If loans are necessary, exhaust federal loan options first, as they typically offer better terms than private loans.

Mistake 5: not considering return on investment

Sending your child to college is an investment in their future, much like buying stock and bonds or starting a business. You want to ensure that the investment will pay off. Research potential colleges and their programs to understand the return on investment (ROI). Look into graduation rates, average starting salaries for graduates, and job placement rates. This can help you and your child make informed decisions about which schools and programs offer the best value.

mistake 6: forgetting to plan for financial aid

Navigating the financial aid process can feel like trying to put together a puzzle without all the pieces. Many families don’t take full advantage of available financial aid because they don’t understand the process or miss important deadlines. Complete the Free Application for Federal Student Aid (FAFSA) as soon as possible after October 1 of your child’s senior year of high school. This will determine your eligibility for federal aid, including grants, work-study programs, and loans. Some states and colleges also use FAFSA information to award their own aid, so don’t miss out.

Mistake 7: neglecting to have the “money talk” with your child

Talking about money with your child can be as uncomfortable as discussing the birds and the bees, but it’s just as important. Many parents avoid this conversation, leading to misunderstandings and unrealistic expectations. Be open and honest about what you can afford and the importance of making wise financial decisions. Discuss the implications of taking on debt, the value of budgeting, and the importance of working while in school. Preparing your child for the financial realities of college will set them up for success.

mistake 8: overlooking the impact on your retirement

Remember, saving for college shouldn’t come at the expense of your retirement. It’s like putting all your energy into building a college fund while neglecting to maintain your own home. Your child can take out loans for college, but you can’t take out loans for retirement. Make sure you’re contributing enough to your retirement accounts and consider seeking the help of a financial advisor to balance both goals effectively.

Mistake 9: not exploring all college payment options

Paying for college doesn’t have to be a one-size-fits-all approach. It’s like shopping for a car: you wouldn’t just go with the first model you see without comparing options. Explore all possible payment options, including tuition payment plans offered by many colleges. These plans can spread out payments over several months, making it easier to manage cash flow without taking on debt. Additionally, look into tax credits and deductions available for education expenses, such as the American Opportunity Tax Credit and the Lifetime Learning Credit.

mistake 10: overestimating future earnings

It’s easy to assume that your child will land a high-paying job right after graduation, but this can be as risky as betting on a lottery ticket. Be realistic about potential earnings and job prospects in your child’s chosen field. Encourage them to pursue internships, co-op programs, and networking opportunities while in school to enhance their employability after graduation. A practical approach to career planning can help manage expectations and financial planning.

Navigating the financial aspects of paying for college can be daunting, but avoiding these common mistakes can make the journey smoother. Start early, do your homework, and have open conversations with your child about finances. With careful planning and a strategic approach, you can help ensure that your child’s college education is a worthwhile investment without derailing your own financial goals. Just like a well-planned road trip, a thoughtful approach to college funding can help you reach your destination with fewer bumps along the way.

Ivan Havrylyan
How 529 Plans Can Help Grandparents Leave a Lasting Legacy

There’s no greater joy than watching your grandchildren grow and flourish. From their first steps to their first day at school, you’ve been there, cheering them on every step of the way. Now, imagine leaving a legacy that continues to support and cheer them on long after you’re gone. Sounds wonderful, doesn’t it? That’s exactly what a 529 plan can do. Think of it as a time capsule of love, wisdom, and support that will help your grandchildren thrive in their educational journey.


What’s a 529 plan?

Before we dive into the heart of it, let’s take a moment to understand what a 529 plan is. Named after Section 529 of the Internal Revenue Code, a 529 plan is a tax-advantaged savings plan designed to encourage saving for future education costs. Much like how you might set aside a portion of your garden to plant seeds that will grow into something beautiful and bountiful, a 529 plan allows you to set aside money for your grandchild’s education, watching it grow over time.

How a 529 Plan Works

Think of a 529 plan like a savings account, specifically designed for education. Here’s a breakdown:

1. Tax Advantages

 Just like the satisfaction of knowing your garden is growing pesticide-free, the money you put into a 529 plan grows tax-free. When the time comes to use the funds for qualified educational expenses, withdrawals are also tax-free. Furthermore, many states offer an income tax deduction for contributions up to a specific limit, usually $10,000 per individual or $20,000 per couple.

2.Flexibility

Picture this: you plant a tree in your garden that can adapt and thrive in various climates. Similarly, 529 plans offer flexibility. They can be used for a wide range of educational expenses, not just college tuition and fees:

**Elementary or secondary school tuition

**Vocational school and trade school tuition and fees

**Apprenticeship programs

**Off-campus housing

**Food and meal plans

**Books, computers, and supplies

**Even student loan repayments

3.Control

Unlike a trust fund where the beneficiary might take control at a certain age, with a 529 plan, you maintain control over the funds. It’s like keeping the key to the treasure chest until you decide it’s time to open it.

4. High Contribution Limits

Unlike other savings plans, 529 plans typically have high contribution limits, allowing you to contribute more than you might with other accounts. This is akin to having a vast plot of land where you can plant as many trees and flowers as you want.

Leaving a Legacy: The Emotional and Financial Impact

Now, let’s talk about why a 529 plan is a powerful tool for leaving a lasting legacy. As grandparents, you’ve accumulated wisdom and resources over the years. Here’s how a 529 plan aligns with your desire to support your grandchildren’s future:

1. Financial Security

 Just as a sturdy tree provides shade and shelter, a 529 plan provides financial security. The cost of education continues to rise, and many young people graduate with significant debt. By contributing to a 529 plan, you’re giving your grandchildren a head start, free from the heavy burden of student loans.

2. Value of Education

Education is the key to unlocking a world of opportunities. By investing in your grandchild’s education, you’re not just giving them money; you’re giving them the tools to build a better future. It’s like teaching them to fish rather than just giving them a fish.

3. Building Dreams

Every child has dreams. Whether they aspire to be a doctor, an artist, an engineer, or an entrepreneur, a 529 plan can help make those dreams a reality. It’s like providing them with a treasure map, guiding them to their own pot of gold.

Getting Started with a 529 Plan

Starting a 529 plan is simpler than you might think. Here’s a step-by-step guide to get you started:

1.Research and Choose a 529 Plan

Much like choosing the best seeds for your garden, it’s important to research and select the right 529 plan. Each state offers its own 529 plan with different benefits and features. Compare the options to find the one that best suits your needs.

2. Open an Account

 Once you’ve selected a plan, opening an account is straightforward. You’ll need some basic information about yourself and your grandchild, including their Social Security number.

3. Contribute Regularly

Just as a garden needs regular watering, your 529 plan will thrive with consistent contributions. You can set up automatic contributions to make saving easier. Remember, even small amounts add up over time.

4. Monitor and Adjust

Keep an eye on your plan’s performance and make adjustments as needed. It’s like tending to your garden, ensuring it remains healthy and vibrant.

 

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I transfer a 529 plan to another grandchild if needed?

Absolutely! One of the great features of a 529 plan is its flexibility. If one grandchild doesn’t need the funds, you can transfer the plan to another qualified family member without penalties.

What happens if my grandchild gets a scholarship?

First of all, congratulations! Scholarships are fantastic. If your grandchild receives a scholarship, you can withdraw the amount of the scholarship from the 529 plan without paying penalties, though you may have to pay taxes on the earnings.

Are there any drawbacks?

Like any investment, 529 plans come with risks. The value of your investment can fluctuate based on market conditions. It’s important to consider these factors and possibly consult a financial advisor.

 

The Gift that Keeps on Giving

Illinois First Steps, launched in 2023, is a college savings starter program that provides a one-time $50 seed deposit into the 529 college savings accounts of children born or adopted by Illinois residents. Administered by the Office of the Illinois State Treasurer and established by the Illinois General Assembly, this initiative aims to assist Illinois families in beginning their savings for the increasing costs of higher education and training.

In conclusion, a 529 plan is more than just a financial tool; it’s a gift that keeps on giving. It’s the educational equivalent of planting a tree whose shade you may not sit under, but whose benefits will be enjoyed by future generations. By starting a 529 plan for your grandchild, you’re planting seeds of knowledge, opportunity, and love that will grow and flourish long into the future.

So, dear grandparents, as you think about the legacy you want to leave, consider the profound impact a 529 plan can have. It’s a way to continue supporting your grandchildren, nurturing their dreams, and helping them build a bright and successful future. And remember, the love and wisdom you impart today will bloom for many years to come, much like the beautiful garden you’ve tended with care and devotion.

Happy planting, and here’s to a legacy that lasts!

 
 

Partnering with Outside The Box Financial Planning (OTBFP) offers numerous benefits for individuals seeking college planning, retirement planning, small business support, wealth management, and beyond.  As a fee-only fiduciary with a comprehensive approach, unbiased advice,  and transparent fee structure, OTBFP acts as a trusted advisor who prioritizes your best interests. Click here to schedule a complimentary “Fit” meeting to determine if we would make a good mutual fit.

Remember, financial decisions have long-lasting implications, and working with a professional like the financial professionals of Outside The Box Financial Planning can provide the expertise and guidance necessary to make informed choices that align with your financial aspirations.

Ivan Havrylyan